IT
was meant to be the O'Rourke's dream home in a new
Ballymun.
But
the three bedroomed house they moved into at Belclare
Drive on Halloween night of 2001 has turned into a
horror show for the family of four.
And
some of their neighbours who started a new life in
what were the first nine homes to be built as part
of the regeneration of Ballymun said they are also
encountering numerous problems, including cracks in
the walls, faulty window ledges and loose floorboards.
In fact, when An Taoiseach Bertie Ahern officially
launched the first Ballymun Regeneration dwellings,
he did so at Shangan Crescent in February 2002 - Belclare
Drive was ignored and there was never any official
launch there.
Mary
O'Rourke and her husband Myles - the second family
to receive keys to their home in the entire regeneration
project - told The Northside People they believe their
house to be so structurally unsound that they fear
it could subside.
When
workers attended to a crack in the living room wall
last week, a concrete block fell out, while our photos
on page two show the state of the walls in the kitchen
and her son's bedroom.
"We
knew there were problems with these houses only weeks
after moving into them and after 10 weeks, all the
residents came together and held a meeting,"
said Mary O'Rourke.
"There
are times when we can even feel the house move.
"Even
the ventilation in the bathroom spooks me the way
it opens and closes. The simplest of things were done
arseways. How does a house get this far without them
realising something's wrong? This place is their best
kept secret."
Ms O'Rourke told The Northside People they don't want
to leave their home but if it's proven by engineers
that the house is subsiding they will have no choice
but to get out.
"Even
if they offered to move everyone on the road to somewhere
else while they sorted it out, I think we'd agree
to that," she said.
A
structural inspection was carried out on the O'Rourke
home - built by leading Irish builders, McCabe's -
by consulting engineers Michael Punch and Partners
in March of this year. It reported cracks to walls
in the first floor bathroom, living room, the three
bedrooms, the dining room and externally, while floorboards
were loose and uneven in the landing.
The report concluded that "it is clear a number
of cracks, both hairline and larger, have opened up
in this dwelling", and said the cause of cracking
is more likely to be related to "workmanship,
deficient materials, raking out of joints or inadequate
drying out".
A further updated report in August said cracks had
been chased out and approved and the construction
was in accordance with the specified structural details,
although there should be a visual monitoring of cracks
every two months.
Cllr Dessie Ellis (SF), who has visited the homes,
said there seems to be "an awful lot of things
wrong" with the development, adding that the
O'Rourke home was the worst. Mr Ellis said he had
questioned handing the contract for a 500 home plus
hotel development at Fairlawn (beside Tolka Valley
Park) in Finglas to McCabe's when the planning application
arose at a Dublin City Council North West Area Committee
meeting.
Neither a spokesperson for Ballymun Regeneration Ltd
nor Padraig Brennan, contracts manager for McCabe
Builders, were available for comment at the time of
going to press.